Section 8 Reasonable Accommodation Requests: A Guide for Tenants and Landlords

The Fair Housing Act requires housing providers to make reasonable accommodations for people with disabilities, and this obligation extends to both public housing authorities administering the Section 8 program and private landlords who accept voucher holders. A reasonable accommodation is a change to rules, policies, practices, or services that allows a person with a disability to have equal opportunity to use and enjoy their housing, and refusing to grant a reasonable request when one is needed because of a disability constitutes housing discrimination under federal law. For Section 8 participants in New York City, understanding how to request accommodations from NYCHA and what landlords must provide helps ensure that disability-related housing needs are met throughout the voucher process.

What Qualifies as a Disability

Under fair housing law, a person has a disability if they have a physical, mental, or emotional impairment that substantially limits one or more major life activities, have a record of such impairment, or are regarded as having such an impairment. Major life activities include things like walking, seeing, hearing, breathing, learning, working, caring for oneself, and performing manual tasks. The definition is broad and encompasses conditions that may not be immediately visible, including chronic health conditions like asthma or diabetes, mental health conditions like depression or anxiety, and cognitive impairments that affect daily functioning.

If you receive disability benefits such as SSI, SSDI, or certain state disability payments, NYCHA will generally consider you to meet the definition of disabled for reasonable accommodation purposes. However, you do not need to receive disability benefits to qualify, and NYCHA cannot require that you prove disability through any particular form of documentation. A statement from a healthcare provider, social worker, or other knowledgeable professional explaining your condition and its effect on your housing needs is typically sufficient.

Current illegal drug use disqualifies someone from disability protections, but a history of substance use disorder where the person is no longer using does qualify as a disability under fair housing law. This distinction matters because it affects whether someone who has struggled with addiction can request accommodations related to their recovery.

Types of Reasonable Accommodations from NYCHA

NYCHA provides reasonable accommodations to Section 8 applicants, voucher holders, and tenants throughout every stage of the program. The accommodations available fall into several categories depending on what aspect of the program is creating a barrier for the person with a disability.

For voucher search and leasing, common accommodations include extended voucher search time beyond the standard 180 days when a disability makes it harder to locate suitable housing, assistance finding accessible units including provision of current listings of available accessible apartments, higher payment standards when a person with a disability needs a unit that costs more than the standard payment would cover (though NYCHA may need HUD approval for payment standards above a certain threshold), and larger voucher bedroom sizes when a disability requires additional space, such as for medical equipment or a live-in aide.

For program participation, accommodations may include home visits for briefings or interviews when a person cannot travel to NYCHA offices, assistance completing annual recertification documents, extended deadlines for submitting required paperwork, documents provided in accessible formats such as large print, Braille, or audio for people with visual impairments, and sign language interpreters or certified deaf interpreters for people who are deaf or hard of hearing.

For transfers, a person with a disability may request a transfer voucher to move to a different unit when their current housing does not meet their disability-related needs, or when they need to relocate to be closer to medical care or support services. The transfer must be connected to the disability and its effects on the person's housing situation.

NYCHA also allows renting from a relative as a reasonable accommodation in limited circumstances. Federal rules generally prohibit Section 8 tenants from renting units owned by relatives, but NYCHA may approve this arrangement if the tenant establishes that it is necessary because of a disability and the relative owner does not live in the unit.

Requesting an Accommodation from NYCHA

To request a reasonable accommodation from NYCHA for Section 8, you can submit a completed Request for a Reasonable Accommodation form (NYCHA Form 059.109 for Section 8) through the Self-Service Portal, by mail, or in person at a Walk-in Center. The form asks you to identify what accommodation you are requesting, explain why you need it, and provide information about the disability that creates the need. You do not have to disclose your specific diagnosis, but you must explain enough about your limitations that NYCHA can understand the connection between your disability and the accommodation you are requesting.

NYCHA will likely ask for medical verification using Form 040.426, which your healthcare provider completes. The form asks the provider to confirm that you have a disability without requiring them to disclose the specific condition, and to explain how the requested accommodation addresses your disability-related limitations. The provider can be a doctor, nurse, social worker, therapist, or other professional with knowledge of your condition.

If your disability is obvious or already known to NYCHA, and if the need for the accommodation is also readily apparent, NYCHA may not require additional verification. For example, if a wheelchair user requests an accessible parking space, the need is obvious from the visible disability. But for non-obvious conditions like chronic pain, mental health conditions, or learning disabilities, verification will typically be required.

NYCHA must respond to reasonable accommodation requests within 30 days in most cases. If they need more time to evaluate a complex request, they must notify you in writing and explain why. If NYCHA denies your request, you can challenge the decision through an informal hearing, and the denial notice should explain how to request one. If you missed a deadline for requesting a hearing because of your disability, you can request reinstatement of your hearing rights as a reasonable accommodation.

Landlord Obligations for Reasonable Accommodations

Private landlords who rent to Section 8 tenants have independent obligations under the Fair Housing Act to provide reasonable accommodations, separate from whatever NYCHA provides through the voucher program. A landlord cannot refuse to rent to someone because they might need accommodations, cannot treat tenants with disabilities differently than other tenants, and must grant reasonable accommodation requests when the tenant demonstrates a disability-related need.

Common accommodation requests that landlords receive include allowing assistance animals in buildings with no-pet policies (this is one of the most frequent requests and landlords must allow it when properly documented), assigning a specific parking space to a tenant with mobility limitations, allowing a tenant to install grab bars, ramps, or other accessibility modifications, providing an accessible mailbox location, allowing early lease termination when a disability requires relocation, and making exceptions to guest policies for live-in aides or regular caregivers.

A landlord can ask for documentation establishing that the person has a disability and that the accommodation is necessary, but cannot demand specific medical records or diagnoses. A letter from a healthcare provider or other knowledgeable professional explaining the need is sufficient. The landlord cannot charge extra rent or fees for providing an accommodation, though for physical modifications (as opposed to policy changes), the tenant may be responsible for the cost in private housing.

If a landlord refuses to provide a reasonable accommodation, the tenant can file a complaint with HUD's Office of Fair Housing and Equal Opportunity, file a complaint with the New York State Division of Human Rights, or file a lawsuit in court. NYCHA will also provide information about filing discrimination complaints if an owner refuses to allow an accommodation for a Section 8 tenant.

Reasonable Modifications vs. Reasonable Accommodations

The terms are related but distinct. A reasonable accommodation is a change to rules, policies, or practices. A reasonable modification is a physical change to the structure of the dwelling or common areas. Both are required under fair housing law, but who pays for them differs.

For policy accommodations like allowing an assistance animal or assigning a parking space, the landlord bears any cost. For physical modifications like installing grab bars or widening doorways, the rules depend on the type of housing. In private rental housing, the tenant generally pays for modifications but the landlord must permit them. In federally subsidized housing including project-based Section 8, the landlord typically pays for modifications. For tenant-based Section 8 in private housing, the tenant usually pays but some modifications may be covered through other programs.

When a tenant pays for modifications, the landlord can require that work be done professionally and to code, but cannot dictate which contractor the tenant uses. The landlord can also require the tenant to restore the unit to its original condition when moving out, but only if the modification would limit the landlord's ability to re-rent the unit, and the landlord cannot require removal of modifications that would not affect re-renting, like grab bars.

Assistance Animals

Assistance animals, including both service animals and emotional support animals, are one of the most common reasonable accommodation requests in Section 8 housing. Under fair housing law, a landlord must allow an assistance animal even in housing with no-pet policies, and cannot charge pet deposits or pet rent for assistance animals because they are not pets under the law.

For service animals trained to perform specific tasks for a person with a disability, no documentation is required if the disability and the animal's function are obvious. For emotional support animals that provide therapeutic benefit through companionship, the landlord can request documentation from a healthcare provider establishing that the person has a disability and that the animal provides disability-related support.

Landlords cannot impose breed or weight restrictions on assistance animals, though they can deny an accommodation if a specific animal poses a direct threat to the health or safety of others based on the animal's actual behavior, not stereotypes about breeds. Landlords also cannot require that assistance animals be registered with any service or wear identifying vests.

NYCHA exempts assistance animals from pet registration fees, weight limits, and breed restrictions that might otherwise apply. If you have an assistance animal and are searching for Section 8 housing, landlords cannot reject your application because of the animal if you provide appropriate documentation of your disability-related need.

Practical Tips for Tenants

Make your accommodation request as soon as you identify the need, even before it becomes urgent. You can request accommodations at any point during the application process or tenancy, but waiting until you face an adverse action like eviction makes the situation more difficult. Put your request in writing so there is a record, even though oral requests are legally sufficient to trigger the landlord's or NYCHA's obligation to respond.

Be specific about what you need and why. A vague request like "I need help because of my disability" is harder for the housing provider to evaluate than a specific request like "I need an assigned parking space near the building entrance because I have limited mobility and cannot walk long distances." Connect the accommodation to your disability without necessarily disclosing your diagnosis.

Keep copies of everything you submit and document all interactions related to your request. If your request is denied or ignored, having a paper trail makes it easier to pursue your rights through a complaint or hearing.

Practical Tips for Landlords

Respond to accommodation requests promptly and in good faith. Ignoring a request or delaying unreasonably can itself constitute discrimination. If you need more information to evaluate the request, ask for it specifically rather than simply denying the request.

You can deny a request if it would impose an undue financial or administrative burden, or if it would fundamentally alter the nature of your housing operation, but these defenses are narrow and fact-specific. Before denying, consider whether there is an alternative accommodation that would meet the tenant's needs without the burden you are concerned about. Engaging in an interactive process with the tenant to find a workable solution is both legally required and practically wise.

If you have questions about whether a particular accommodation is required, consult with an attorney or fair housing organization before denying the request. The penalties for unlawful denial can include damages, attorney's fees, and civil penalties.

Resources

For NYCHA Section 8 reasonable accommodation requests, contact the Customer Contact Center at 718-707-7771 or NYCHA's Services for People with Disabilities at 212-306-4652. The NYCHA Reasonable Accommodation page has downloadable forms including the Request for Reasonable Accommodation (Form 059.109) and Medical Verification form (Form 040.426). For HPD-administered voucher programs, use HPD's Reasonable Accommodation Request Form and contact Client Services at 917-286-4300.

For general fair housing guidance, the HUD/DOJ Joint Statement on Reasonable Accommodations explains federal requirements in detail. To file a discrimination complaint, contact HUD's Office of Fair Housing at 1-800-669-9777.

If you are looking for Section 8 housing that meets your accessibility needs, browse VoucherMatch listings to find available units. Landlords can list accessible properties to connect with voucher holders who need them.

---

Reasonable accommodations ensure that people with disabilities have equal access to housing. Understanding your rights and responsibilities makes the process work for everyone.